Skip to main content
to rake over the coals

to rake over the coals

4 7.9
Scold someone very strongly for a mistake
  • idiom
  • Informal
translation icon : criticar duramente
  • After his poor performance, the coach didn't hold back and raked him over the coals in front of the team.
  • get raked over the coals
  • just raked over the coals

Examples

  • President's getting raked over the coals over this Manson trial declaration.

  • Herman would have gotten raked over the coals if he hadn't said anything to condemn what was on the rock, whether it had to do with Perry's family or not.

    Blog text (1)
  • And I'm getting raked over the coals because of a little dinner.

  • The way he was raked over the coals for "Travelgate."

    Blog text (17)
  • She rakes us over the coals.

    Academic text (1998)
  • On the other hand, the White House made no bones about raking liberals and progressives over the coals.

    Blog text (14)
  • There's a reason that Romney's being raked over the coals for trying to use this against Obama.

    Blog text (19)
  • Sandra Fluke was raked over the coals for being a smart, articulate woman.

    Blog text (33)
  • I was once raked over the coals for suggesting something about Ezra Klein's employment, including by John Cole himself, to the point where a friend from work who also reads this site said I was being massacred.

    Blog text (29)
  • The politician was raked over the coals by the press for his controversial remarks.

Synonyms

to trash
vsto rake over the coals
  • Offensive
70 5.8

To say very bad things about someone or something

is more focused on severe reprimand rather than general disparagement
to scold
vsto rake over the coals
55 2.2

Speak angrily to someone who has done something wrong

is harsher and implies more severe or cutting verbal attack
to let him have it
vsto rake over the coals
  • Informal
44 8.1

To tell someone angrily that they did something wrong

is comparable but often suggests a more formal or public setting
to give someone hell
vsto rake over the coals
  • Informal
37 8.1

To scold someone very strongly for something they did

is like that but may stress public or repeated rebuke
to come down
vsto rake over the coals
  • Informal
37 5.9

To criticize someone strongly

is more focused on intense personal shaming or thoroughness
to chastise
vsto rake over the coals
  • Formal
33 7.6

To scold someone strongly for doing something wrong

is similar but often more forceful and caustic
to reprimand
vsto rake over the coals
  • Formal
33 6.1

To tell someone they did something wrong, usually by a person in charge

is more emotionally intense and harsher in tone
to censure
vsto rake over the coals
  • Formal
26 7.7

To express strong disapproval of someone, often in an official statement

is more about harsh personal shaming or angry verbal attack
to rebuke
vsto rake over the coals
  • Formal
26 6.9

To tell someone firmly that you do not approve of their actions

is more about harsh personal shaming rather than official censure
to revile
vsto rake over the coals
  • Offensive
23 8.2

To say angry, insulting things about someone or something

is more about strong punitive words aimed at correction
to take to task
vsto rake over the coals
18 6.3

To scold someone strongly for a mistake

is broader, implying very strong and often personal chastisement
to scorch
vsto rake over the coals
15 7.3

To severely criticize someone or something

is more focused on prolonged personal reprimand rather than public denunciation
to castigate
vsto rake over the coals
  • Formal
14 8.8

To criticize or punish someone very harshly

leans more toward angry personal attack rather than formal punishment
to chew out
vsto rake over the coals
  • Informal
13 7.0

Scold someone angrily in front of others

is similar but implies even more severe or prolonged criticism
to lambast
vsto rake over the coals
12 8.2

To criticize someone very strongly and angrily

is similar but may suggest even greater duration or thoroughness
to let someone have it
vsto rake over the coals
  • Informal
11 8.1

To angrily tell someone off

is more intensive and may imply prolonged verbal attack
to excoriate
vsto rake over the coals
  • Literature
9 9.8

To criticize someone or something very harshly in public

is similar but with a more personal, punitive tone
to harsh on
vsto rake over the coals
  • Informal
7 5.8

Criticize someone in a very unkind way

is comparable but often involves more active verbal punishment
to give someone the business
vsto rake over the coals
  • Informal
5 8.3

Tell someone angrily that they did something wrong

is harsher and implies more thorough verbal punishment
to call on the carpet
vsto rake over the coals
  • Archaic
3 7.9

To tell someone strongly that they have done something wrong, often in front of others

is similar but less tied to formal authority and more general
to upbraid
vsto rake over the coals
  • Formal
3 8.8

To scold someone strongly for something they did wrong

is generally harsher and may be more personal and prolonged
to chew up
vsto rake over the coals
  • Informal
2 7.1

To scold someone angrily and severely

is about especially severe and thorough verbal punishment
to tear (someone) a new one
vsto rake over the coals
  • Offensive
2 9.9

To scold someone angrily

is equally severe but may stress repeated or thorough reproach
to give hell
vsto rake over the coals
  • Informal
1 8.1

To scold or punish someone angrily for something they did wrong

is similar but may focus more on shaming than on punishment
to give someone what for
vsto rake over the coals
  • Informal
1 8.7

Tell someone angrily that they did something wrong

is similar but implies even harsher or sustained criticism
to lambaste
vsto rake over the coals
1 8.0

To criticize someone or something very strongly in public

is more about intense personal rebuke rather than public critique
to scald
vsto rake over the coals
1 8.1

To criticize someone or something very harshly

is similar but implies a longer, more exhaustive chastising
to call down
vsto rake over the coals
  • Informal
1 6.8

Tell someone angrily that they did something wrong

is more forceful and suggests greater emotional intensity
to haul over the coals
vsto rake over the coals
  • Informal
1 8.6

To scold someone very strongly for a mistake

is virtually identical in meaning but may be more idiomatic
to brush down
vsto rake over the coals
  • Informal
7.9

To tell someone off angrily

is more intense and suggests heavier verbal punishment
to get on someone's grill
vsto rake over the coals
  • Slang
9.9

To tell someone angrily that you do not like what they did

is similar but can be less about direct confrontation and more severe
to throw brickbats
vsto rake over the coals
  • Literature
8.9

Attack someone with strong words in public

is similar but stresses personal, direct, and severe reprimand
to vituperate
vsto rake over the coals
  • Offensive
9.9

To criticize someone angrily using harsh words

is closer to direct severe reprimand than broad abusive attack
to clapperclaw
vsto rake over the coals
  • Offensive
9.9

To attack someone with angry words

is similar but usually aims at formal or corrective rebuke
to chap someone's hide
vsto rake over the coals
  • Informal
9.3

To scold someone angrily for something they did

is similar but emphasizes strong verbal chastisement without threats

Antonyms

161 1.0

Words or actions that show admiration for someone

How Harsh

to berate
36 7.2
to rake over the coals
  • Informal
4 7.9
to rebuke
  • Formal
26 6.9
to reprimand
  • Formal
33 6.1
to scold
55 2.2

Surface Forms

rake over the coals infinitive
raked over the coals past participle
raking over the coals present participle
rakes over the coals third person singular

Morphology

rake + over + the + coal

Although 'rake' and 'coal' have clear literal meanings, the idiomatic sense 'to criticize or reprimand severely' is not directly predictable from 'rake' (to scrape or comb) + 'coal' (hot embers). Any metaphorical link (heat/pain) is abstract and culturally specific, so a B1 learner who knows the words would likely not infer the intended meaning without prior exposure.

Etymology

The idiom rake over the coals may come from the image of someone using a rake to stir hot coals in a fire, sending heat and sparks toward the person near the fire. That's why today it means 'to criticize or scold someone very severely'.