Skip to main content
antinomy

antinomy

1 9.9
A conflict between two ideas that both seem true
  • noun
  • /ænˈtɪnəmi/
  • Formal
translation icon : antinomía
  • Many debates in ethics stem from the antinomy between individual rights and the common good.

He tells us the antinomy of the moral view of the world.

Autoplay Next

Examples

  • The dilemma in the antinomy of alienation and oppression, as Graeber states it, rests in the discrepancies in the moral weight of struggle.

    Academic text (2011)
  • One should also not forget the other famous antinomy, that between action and theory.

    Academic text (1991)
  • He tells us the antinomy of the moral view of the world.

  • These are are antinomies that the poem is exploring.

  • In the course of discussing related issues in our "free exchange," he had remarked: "... and it is here that we find the antinomy; there are a certain number of conditions for the existence of a culture.

    Academic text (2002)
  • In her encounter with the nomad, Geula tries desperately to maintain the antinomy of savage versus culture.

    Academic text (2001)
  • Hegel's point is rather, why should contradictions, antinomies, be only subjective?

  • In philosophy, the antinomy between freedom and determinism raises deep questions about human agency.

  • The antinomy of truth versus perception often leads to complex discussions in epistemology.

Synonyms

contradiction
vsantinomy
117 4.3

A situation where two ideas or statements cannot both be true

is a clash between two plausible principles rather than any broad opposition
paradox
vsantinomy
99 7.1

A situation or statement that seems both true and false at the same time

is a clash between two plausible principles rather than a surprising oddity
6 6.8

A statement that says two things that cannot both be true

highlights a clash between two plausible principles rather than impossible wording
self-contradiction
vsantinomy
1 7.5

A situation when a person's words or beliefs say opposite things

focuses on conflict between two plausible principles, not internal inconsistency

How Contradictory

antinomy
  • Formal
1 9.9
contradiction
117 4.3
paradox
99 7.1
tension
  • Literature
50 4.2
harmony
146 2.5

Surface Forms

antinomy singular
antinomies plural

Morphology

antinomy = anti + nom + y

Although the word can be segmented as anti- + nom- + -y, its meaning as a logical contradiction is not directly predictable from those parts for most learners.

Etymology

Antinomy comes from Greek parts anti- 'against' and nomos 'law', the same -nomy you see in economy. So an antinomy is like two 'laws' or rules that oppose each other, a contradiction where both ideas seem reasonable.