pleading in the alternative
- noun
- Formal
- During the trial, he used a pleading in the alternative strategy to address both possible outcomes of the case.
Examples
-
The lawyer submitted a pleading in the alternative, presenting two different claims for the court to consider.
-
Next, perhaps pleading in the alternative in the original motion, i.e., seeking termination or at the very least modification in the initial application.
Blog text (4) -
By filing a pleading in the alternative, she aimed to strengthen her position by offering multiple arguments.
Synonyms
A court paper that gives different, sometimes opposite, versions of facts so a lawyer can use any that fit
Surface Forms
Morphology
pleading + in + the + alternative
The phrase literally combines 'pleading' (a legal filing) with 'in the alternative' (meaning 'alternatively' or 'as another option'), so a learner who knows those words can infer it refers to a pleading that offers alternative claims. However, the expression is specialized legal register and the precise practice of presenting multiple distinct sets of facts or claims is a technical usage that a B1 learner without legal exposure may not fully grasp, making the transparency partial.
Etymology
The legal term pleading in the alternative is like a lawyer telling two different stories to a judge. The lawyer gives one pleading and then another in the alternative, saying 'this happened' or 'if not, that happened', so one of the options will match the facts, which is why it means 'presenting different arguments so one will work'.