Skip to main content
pilpul

pilpul

9.9
A way of arguing that focuses on small unimportant differences and confuses the issue
  • noun
  • /ˈpɪlˌpʊl/
  • Jargon
translation icon : pilpul
  • During the debate, the candidate used pilpul to avoid giving a straight answer to the question.

Examples

  • That is another example of extreme hairsplitting and an extrapolation of a "State" concept that is not warranted by the text, i.e., pilpul.

    Blog text (29)
  • That is an example of unwarranted extrapolation or pilpul.

    Blog text (29)
  • There's nothing anti-Semitic about calling extreme hairsplitting or extrapolation of contentious and doubtful concepts from texts "pilpul."

    Blog text (29)
  • The lawyer's argument was filled with pilpul, making it hard to follow his main point.

  • His explanation descended into pilpul, leaving the audience confused rather than enlightened.

Synonyms

quibble
vspilpul
11 6.8

A small complaint about unimportant details used to avoid the main point

is about fine, specious splitting of ideas rather than simple small objections
hair-splitting
vspilpul
  • Informal
1 7.7

Making very small, unimportant differences in an argument or discussion

is a specific term for the same overly subtle, specious reasoning
specious argument
vspilpul
  • Formal
1 8.5

A reason that seems good but is actually wrong

is subtler, emphasizing tiny distinctions rather than mere false appearance
hairsplitting
vspilpul
1 8.2

Paying too much attention to small unimportant details in a debate

is a slightly more technical or foreign label for that same habit
casuistry
vspilpul
1 9.9

Using clever but wrong reasoning to avoid giving a clear answer

is more general hair splitting, not limited to moral argumentation
Jesuitic reasoning
vspilpul
  • Offensive
9.9

Very complicated, tricky argument that tries to hide the truth

focuses more narrowly on subtle, hair splitting rather than intentional evasion
quiddity
vspilpul
  • Formal
9.9

A small, unimportant objection that distracts from the main point

is broader, covering any overly subtle or sophistical line of argument

Surface Forms

pilpul singular
pilpuls plural

Etymology

Pilpul comes from the Hebrew word pilpel, 'pepper' or 'sharpness', giving the image of many small, sharp points. So pilpul can also mean hair-splitting or an overly subtle argument that confuses more than it helps.