Skip to main content
cafeteria Catholic

cafeteria Catholic

1 9.9
A Catholic who accepts some Church teachings but rejects others
  • noun
  • /ˌkæfəˈtɪəriə ˈkæθlɪk/
  • Slur
translation icon : católico de cafetería
  • Many people identify as cafeteria Catholics because they feel comfortable choosing which beliefs to follow.

Examples

  • The "other" cafeteria Catholics aren't guilty of any crime exactly.

    Blog text (3)
  • As a cafeteria Catholic, she emphasizes certain teachings while ignoring others that do not resonate with her.

  • The ambiguity frustrates the "other" cafeteria Catholic to no end, so they make up their own rules.

    Blog text (3)
  • Lest you think I'm writing about the "other" cafeteria Catholic as one standing in judgment, I want to give you a little backstory.

    Blog text (3)
  • The "other" cafeteria Catholic may be able to proof-text from the Catechism or the Scripture if you challenge some doctrine, but he hasn't gone any deeper.

    Blog text (3)
  • One of the commenters on The Other Cafeteria Catholic, Part I, quite rightly pointed out that lax Catholics and overly zealous Catholics often share a common background.

    Blog text (3)
  • He proudly calls himself a cafeteria Catholic since he embraces some church doctrines but questions others.

Synonyms

nonconformist
vscafeteria Catholic
3 7.4

Not following the usual customs or rules of society

accepts some official teachings and rejects others within the same church

Surface Forms

Morphology

cafeteria + Catholic

The noun phrase uses 'cafeteria' metaphorically to signal a 'pick-and-choose' attitude, so a learner who knows 'cafeteria' and 'Catholic' can infer it refers to a Catholic who selects which doctrines to accept. Because this is a metaphorical and culturally marked extension (the exact nuance of selective adherence may require exposure), it is not fully predictable from the parts.

Etymology

Cafeteria Catholic comes from the image of a person in a cafeteria who fills a tray by 'picking what they like' and leaving the rest. So it describes a Catholic who accepts some church teachings but rejects others.